A Love Island All Stars clash has reportedly erupted over winners Casey O’Gorman and Gabby Allen’s dinner decisions. The pair were spotted on a double date with friends and previous islanders, Tom Clare and Molly Smith, as well as Mitch Taylor and his girlfriend Hayley Griffin. It is thought that the decision to dine out with Mitch didn’t sit well with some of their fellow islanders. It’s alleged that Mitch attempted to “sabotage” Luca Bish and Grace Jackson’s chances of winning the hit ITV dating show, with the islander responsible for revealing so-called texts from Grace. These texts led to a rather uncomfortable moment in the All Stars villa when ex-housemates returned to vote off one couple.

Love Island’s Casey and Mitch
(Image: Instagram/@gabbydawnallen)

During this episode, viewers were shocked as Liv Hawkins claimed Grace had messaged another islander before entering the villa, saying she would “do anything to win”. Liv stated in the episode: “So I’ve seen text messages of Grace just saying to someone that she’ll do whatever it takes to win the show this time from someone back home.” This caused a stir from Grace and Harriet, who defended her best friend, insisting that Grace isn’t the type to play games. Grace denied the allegations, but fans began to question her when former Islander Mitch posted a screenshot of the alleged conversation on his Snapchat. Mitch caused a stir by sharing what appears to be messages exchanged between Grace and an anonymous friend.

Mitch Taylor stirred up some Love Island drama
(Image: Instagram/mitcheltaylor_)

Grace and Luca came in second place
(Image: ITV)

In the conversation, the unnamed friend seemingly tells her, “You’re my winner regardless,” to which Grace allegedly responds with, “Aww, thank you, babe. I will win this time. I’ll do anything.” Mitch, who didn’t reveal where these supposed receipts came from, posted on Snapchat, “I don’t know who the receipts are from; I got sent it loads. All I know is Casey and Gabby won.” Despite his reveal, he later appeared to backtrack during a live chat with followers, saying the messages “could be fake”. A representative for Mitch recently told the Mirror: “Mitch shared something he got sent and asked his followers if it was real or fake. Nothing more or out of the ordinary for social media.” In other Love Island drama, Casey had his phone stolen following his return from South Africa, leaving his private conversations and images vulnerable. His best pal Tom announced on Instagram: “Casey’s had his phone stolen!” He also made a call to action, asking his followers for “any info”, directing them to his messages.

Categorized in:

Amazing, News,

Last Update: March 21, 2025