Get the latest OK! breaking news on WhatsAppOur community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More infoJoin us on WhatsApp Emmerdale fans think they have worked out whose body was dumped in the lake – and who killed them. Amy Wyatt (played by Natalie Jamieson) found herself precariously trapped beneath the ice, and eagle-eyed viewers noticed an additional body in the murky depths. Speculation is rife that it’s none other than Nate Robinson (Jurell Carter) who waved goodbye to village life last year for a fresh start in Shetland. The plot thickened when Amy spotted a hand adorned with a distinctive bracelet – identical to the one Frankie crafted for Nate. Suspicion initially fell on Oliver Farnworth’s John Sugden, as he was seemingly the final villager to cross paths with Nate, reports Leeds Live.
Fans think Nate Robinson was killed
(Image: ITV)
Whispers in the Dales grew louder when John and Tracy (Amy Walsh) mulled over Nate’s abrupt exit, particularly his failure to bid farewell to Frankie. While some viewers are adamant John is behind Nate’s potential demise, a faction believes Tracy’s secret lover, Caleb Milligan (Will Ash), is the real culprit. In a flurry of theories exchanged on a Facebook fan group, one sleuth posted: “If it was Nate under the water, who killed him?” “Caleb killed him, I reckon,” another chimed in confidently.
Emmerdale’s Aaron Dingle and John Sugden
(Image: ITV)
A third concurred, suspecting Caleb acted out of revenge for Nate’s entanglement with Tracy: “I think it will come out that Caleb killed him for what went off with Tracy,” with another supporter adding: “Yes, I totally agree.” Not satisfied with just one mysterious drowning, some fans are gearing up for an even bigger bombshell that there could be multiple lives claimed by the lake, including Anthony (Nicholas Day), father of Ruby (Beth Cordingly). One fan speculated on social media: “Nate was in that lake and I convinced it was John who put him there alongside Anthony, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if that is true.”
Amy spotted a body in the lake
(Image: ITV)
Another responded, suggesting a different theory: “I thought it was Caleb.” A third viewer threw another twist into the mix, saying: “I think Nate and Anthony are both in the lake because John put them there. John will turn out to be a killer if they find Anthony has water in his lungs.” During tonight’s can’t-miss episode, which you can catch up with on ITVX, Amy was tragically drawn from the lake. In the chaos, Leyla (played by Roxi Shahidi) and Kerry (Laura Norton) managed to escape the sinking limo. At the same time, sadly, Suzy (Martelle Edinborough) wasn’t as fortunate and went down with the car following the devastating crash. Paramedics quickly arrived on the scene, speeding the shocked villagers off to the hospital – only to reveal that one of Emmerdale’s own didn’t survive. But the big question on everyone’s lips: who didn’t make it? Emmerdale airs weekdays at 7.30pm on ITV.
