Why your open rate problem is probably a deliverability problem

If your open rates dropped in the last year and nothing else changed, your emails are likely landing in spam or Gmail's Promotions tab. Email deliverability is the quiet reason newsletters underperform, welcome sequences fail to convert, and transactional messages get missed.

Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft tightened their sender rules in 2024, and those rules now apply to anyone sending more than a trickle of email. If you're on Mailchimp, Brevo, Mailjet or Klaviyo and you haven't checked your authentication records recently, this guide walks you through what to fix this week.

Key takeaways

  • Email deliverability depends on three records: SPF, DKIM and DMARC. Without them, bulk senders now reject or spam-fold your mail.
  • Always send from your own domain ([email protected]), never from a free Gmail or Outlook address in bulk campaigns.
  • Warm up new domains and IPs slowly. Volume spikes trigger spam filters.
  • Keep your spam complaint rate under 0.3% and clean inactive subscribers every quarter.
  • Your email platform (Mailchimp, Brevo, Klaviyo, Mailjet) handles the plumbing, but authentication and list hygiene are your job.

What email deliverability actually means

Deliverability is not the same as delivery. Delivery means the receiving server accepted your message. Deliverability means it reached the inbox, not the spam folder or Promotions tab.

A campaign can show 99% delivered in your dashboard while 40% of recipients never see it. Mailbox providers decide placement based on signals they collect about your sending domain, your content, and how previous recipients reacted.

The three signals that matter most:

  1. Authentication - can the receiver prove the email really came from you?
  2. Reputation - how have recipients treated your past emails?
  3. Engagement - do people open, reply, and click, or do they delete and complain?

Fix those three and placement improves on its own.

Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC the right way

These three DNS records are the baseline. Gmail and Yahoo now require all three for bulk senders, and Microsoft is moving the same direction. If you skip any of them, expect your mail to be rejected or junked at scale.

SPF: tell the world who can send for you

SPF (Sender Policy Framework) is a TXT record in your DNS that lists the servers allowed to send email on behalf of your domain. If you send through Brevo, Google Workspace, and a CRM, all three need to be included.

A typical SPF record looks like this:

v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:spf.brevo.com ~all

Watch the 10-lookup limit. SPF breaks silently if you chain too many includes. Use a free SPF checker to audit yours.

DKIM: cryptographically sign every message

DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) adds a signature to each email. The receiver checks the signature against a public key you publish in DNS. Every sending platform you use needs its own DKIM key on your domain.

In Mailchimp, Brevo, Mailjet and Klaviyo, this is done by adding CNAME or TXT records the platform generates for you. Do not skip this step, even if the platform lets you send without it.

DMARC: tell receivers what to do when things fail

DMARC is the policy that ties SPF and DKIM together. A starter record:

v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:[email protected]

Start with p=none to monitor without affecting delivery. After two to four weeks of reports confirming your legitimate mail passes, move to p=quarantine, then eventually p=reject. This stops spoofers from using your domain to phish your customers.

If you only do one thing this week, add DMARC with p=none and a reporting address. You'll see within days whether something is sending mail as you without permission.

Choose the right sending domain and address

The address people see in the From field affects deliverability more than most owners realise.

  • Use your own domain. Sending bulk mail from gmail.com or outlook.com addresses now gets blocked outright by many filters.
  • Avoid noreply@. It trains recipients to ignore your mail and blocks the replies that boost your reputation.
  • Consider a subdomain for marketing. Sending newsletters from news.yourbusiness.com keeps a bad marketing campaign from damaging the reputation of your transactional mail at [email protected].

Say a local bakery sends order confirmations from [email protected] and a weekly newsletter from [email protected]. A spike in newsletter complaints will not block the receipts customers depend on.

Pick a platform that supports deliverability, not just design

Mailchimp, Brevo, Mailjet and Klaviyo all handle authentication, but their defaults, deliverability teams and pricing models differ.

Mailchimp

Strong template editor, mature automation, and a large shared IP pool. Good for beginners sending newsletters and basic drip campaigns. Pricing climbs fast once your list grows past a few thousand contacts.

Brevo

Formerly Sendinblue. Charges per email sent rather than per contact stored, which suits occasional senders with large lists. Includes transactional sending (receipts, password resets) on the same account, which simplifies setup.

Mailjet

Strong on transactional email and developer tooling. Good collaboration features for teams working on templates. Marketing automation is lighter than the others.

Klaviyo

Built for ecommerce. Deep integration with Shopify, WooCommerce and BigCommerce, with segmentation and revenue tracking out of the box. More expensive, but usually pays for itself if you run an online shop with repeat customers.

For a service business sending a weekly newsletter, Brevo or Mailchimp is usually fine. For an online shop, Klaviyo earns its price once you pass a few hundred monthly orders.

Warm up new domains and keep your reputation clean

Moving to a new platform or domain is the moment deliverability most often breaks. Mailbox providers see no history and treat you with suspicion.

A simple warm-up plan

  1. Week 1: send to your 50 to 100 most engaged subscribers only.
  2. Week 2: add the next tier of engaged contacts, roughly doubling volume.
  3. Weeks 3-4: keep doubling, prioritising recipients who opened mail in the last 90 days.
  4. Week 5+: send to your full active list.

Skip anyone who hasn't opened an email in six months. They're more likely to mark you as spam, and their silence tells Gmail you're irrelevant.

Keep complaints and bounces low

  • Remove hard bounces immediately. Most platforms do this automatically.
  • Suppress recipients who haven't opened in 90-180 days, or send them a single win-back email before removing.
  • Make unsubscribe one click, in the header as well as the footer. Gmail and Yahoo now require this for bulk senders.
  • Never buy lists. One bad import can damage a domain's reputation for months.

Write emails that look like mail, not marketing

Content still matters. Spam filters read your subject line, HTML, and link patterns.

  • Match your subject to the body. Clickbait subjects drive opens then deletions, which filters notice.
  • Keep a sensible text-to-image ratio. Emails that are one giant image get flagged.
  • Use your own domain for links. Shortened URLs (bit.ly, t.co) and tracking domains you don't own hurt placement.
  • Include a plain-text version. Most platforms do this automatically, but check the toggle.
  • Avoid ALL CAPS, excessive exclamation marks, and spam-trigger words like 'free money', 'guaranteed', 'act now'.

A short, personal-feeling email with one clear call to action usually outperforms a glossy template, both in engagement and in inbox placement.

Monitor placement before your customers tell you

You can't improve what you don't measure. Your email platform's dashboard shows delivered and opened, but not inbox versus spam placement.

Set up these three checks:

  1. Google Postmaster Tools. Free. Shows your domain reputation, spam rate and authentication pass rates at Gmail.
  2. Microsoft SNDS. Free. Same visibility at Outlook and Hotmail.
  3. A seed list. Create test accounts at Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo and iCloud. Send each campaign to them and check where it landed.

If Google Postmaster shows your spam rate climbing above 0.3%, pause sending and investigate. Waiting until opens collapse is waiting too long.

Pair marketing email with proper business email

Your marketing platform is one half of the picture. The other is the professional email you use day to day for replies, quotes and support.

  • Google Workspace gives you Gmail on your domain, plus Drive, Calendar and Meet. Easiest for small teams already using Google tools.
  • Microsoft 365 gives you Outlook with your domain, plus Word, Excel, Teams and OneDrive. Better fit if your business runs on Office documents.

Both support SPF, DKIM and DMARC. Both let you create shared addresses like hello@, sales@ and support@ without paying for extra licences (as aliases or groups). Both are far more professional, and more deliverable, than sending business mail from a free Gmail address.

If setting up DNS records, migrating old mailboxes, authenticating a platform or warming a new domain feels like a rabbit hole, Henify can handle the email marketing and professional email setup end to end, so your campaigns land in the inbox and your team keeps the addresses they're used to.

A one-week action plan

If you do nothing else, work through this list in order:

  1. Monday: audit your SPF record. Confirm every sending service is included, under the 10-lookup limit.
  2. Tuesday: add DKIM in your marketing platform and your business email provider. Verify both.
  3. Wednesday: publish a DMARC record with p=none and a reporting address.
  4. Thursday: enable Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS for your domain.
  5. Friday: suppress subscribers inactive for 180+ days, then send a short re-engagement email to the 90-180 day group.
  6. Weekend: send a test campaign to a seed list across Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo and iCloud. Note placement.

Repeat the seed list test monthly. Review Postmaster weekly. That's most of what good email deliverability looks like in practice.

FAQ

How long does it take to fix poor email deliverability?

Authentication fixes take hours to apply but 24-48 hours for DNS to propagate. Reputation repair takes longer. Expect four to eight weeks of consistent sending to engaged contacts before placement fully recovers. If the problem was a bought list or a spam-trap hit, the domain may need a longer cooldown.

Do I need DMARC if I already have SPF and DKIM?

Yes. SPF and DKIM prove a message is authentic, but only DMARC tells mailbox providers what to do when a message fails those checks, and it reports who's sending as you. Gmail and Yahoo require DMARC for bulk senders, and most filters now treat its absence as a negative signal.

Can I use the same domain for Google Workspace and Mailchimp or Brevo?

Yes, and it's the standard setup. Your business email runs on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, and your marketing platform sends campaigns from the same domain (or a marketing subdomain). Each service gets its own DKIM key and is added to your SPF record.

What's a good spam complaint rate?

Keep it under 0.1% as a healthy target. Gmail starts penalising senders who exceed 0.3%, and Yahoo follows a similar threshold. If you see a spike, pause, check what you sent, and tighten your list or subject lines before resuming.

Should I buy a dedicated IP for sending?

Only if you send roughly 50,000+ emails per month consistently. Below that volume, a shared IP managed by your platform has better reputation than one you'd need to warm up and maintain yourself. Most small businesses never need a dedicated IP.

Get the authentication right, send to people who want to hear from you, and watch the metrics weekly. That's the whole discipline behind strong email deliverability, and it's within reach for any small business willing to spend one focused week on the setup.